 |
Dr.
Craig L. Symonds
Professor Emeritus, United States Naval Academy
Chief Historian, USS Monitor Center, The Mariner's
Museum
Dr.
Craig L. Symonds is Professor Emeritus at the
United States Naval Academy from which he retired
in 2005. The first person ever to win both the
Naval Academy’s “Excellence in Teaching”
award (1988) and its “Excellence in Research”
award (1998), he also served as History Department
chair from 1988 to 1992, and received the Department
of the Navy’s Superior Civilian Service
medal on three occasions. He served as Professor
of Strategy at the U.S. Naval War College in Newport,
Rhode Island (1971-74) and at the Britannia Royal
Naval College in Dartmouth, England (1994-95).
Symonds
is the author of eleven books, including prize-winning
biographies of Joseph E. Johnston (1992), Patrick
Cleburne (1997), and Franklin Buchanan (1999),
as well as The American Heritage History of the
Battle of Gettysburg (2001). Decision at Sea:
Five Naval Battles that Shaped American History
(2005), won the Theodore and Franklin D. Roosevelt
Prize for Naval History. His most recent book
is Lincoln and His Admirals: Abraham Lincoln,
the U.S. Navy, and the Civil War which will be
published by Oxford University Press this fall.
He
and his wife Marylou live in Annapolis, Maryland.
They have one son and one grandson. |
Since
the two ironclads could not seriously damage one another,
why didn't the VIRGINIA simply ignore the MONITOR at
Hampton Roads and concentrate on the wooden Federal
warships, destroying them like she had the CUMBERLAND
and the CONGRESS?
- C. Helmer, Colonial Heights, Virginia
Dr.
Craig Symonds answers: The VIRGINIA,
like all ships of her era, relied
primarily on firing by ricochet. Since calculating
the range to an enemy ship was difficult, and
since the guns could not be elevated very effectively,
ships of the Civil war era mostly fired at a flat
trajectory and the shells (or solid shot) skipped
across the water toward the target like a stone
skipped across the surface of a lake. At Hampton
Roads, the USS MONITOR interposed itself between
the VIRGINIA and the wooden warship MINNESOTA
(which was the VIRGINIA'S real objective) and
therefore compelled Jones to fight the MONITOR.
When the MONITOR pulled out of the fight briefly
to bring more ammunition up from the magazine,
the VIRGINIA turned its attention to the MINNESOTA,
but the MONITOR returned to interpose itself again
between the two ships. The VIRGINIA therefore
had no option but to fight the MONITOR.
|
|

Monitor collection, NOAA
Battle
between the USS Monitor and the CSS Virginia
on March 9, 1862, as illustrated in Century
Illustrated Magazine, XXIX, March 1885.
|
|
Selected
publications by this author:
Confederate
Admiral: The Life and Wars of Franklin Buchanan
Naval Institute Press (2008)
Joseph
E. Johnston: A Civil War Biography
W. W. Norton & Company (1994)
Stonewall
of the West: Patrick Cleburne and the Civil War
University Press of Kansas (1998)
The
American Heritage History of the Battle of Gettysburg
Harper Collins (2001)
Decision
at Sea: Five Naval Battles that Shaped American History
Oxford University Press, USA (2006)
Return to Questions
The "Ask an Expert" feature is provided as a public service by the author. The opinions and viewpoints expressed herein are those of the person providing the response, and may not represent the opinions or viewpoints of the Commission or its members.
|